Concrete Vs. Paver Patio with Colorado’s Tough Weather: Which is Better?
When designing a patio in Colorado, homeowners face a big decision: concrete or pavers. Colorado’s climate, with its freeze-thaw cycles and dry summers, can be tough on outdoor materials. Making the right choice can help your patio last longer and avoid costly repairs. Here, we’ll compare concrete and paver patios for their durability, maintenance needs, aesthetic options, and more, ending with expert recommendations and important questions to ask your contractor (we don’t want you to end up with any costly surprises).
Paver Patio
Understanding Colorado’s Climate and How It Affects Patios
Colorado homes often settle significantly in their first year, sometimes up to 8 inches. This settling impacts your foundation and landscaping choices. Freezing temperatures in winter and frequent thawing in spring create a “freeze-thaw” cycle that causes the ground to shift and expand. These movements are particularly tough on outdoor surfaces like decks, walkways and patios, which must be able to endure this yearly freeze-thaw cycle without cracking or sinking.
Concrete Patios: Pros and Cons
Concrete patios are a popular choice in Colorado due to their relatively low cost and quick installation. Let’s break down the main considerations for concrete patios in this climate.
1. Durability and Flexibility
Concrete is an affordable option for patios, generally costing around $20 per square foot for a basic installation. However, while concrete is strong, it isn’t always resilient in Colorado. Even with steel reinforcements like wire mesh or rebar, concrete is guaranteed to crack due to the region’s weather conditions. Companies rarely offer warranties on concrete patios because cracking is inevitable (not even covered if it cracks the very next day by most all contractors). When cracks appear, the only option is often to demolish and replace large sections.
2. Maintenance Needs
Maintenance for regular brushed concrete is minimal, though stamped concrete (a more decorative option) requires a sealant every few years to prevent fading. Even with sealing, concrete is prone to erosion and damage over time.
2. Aesthetics and Customization
Concrete patios can be poured in a variety of shapes, sizes, and even colors, making them a flexible choice for basic designs. Sloped areas work well with concrete, as pavers would require additional retaining walls. Stamped concrete can mimic the look of stone or brick, but it tends to be slippery when wet, making it a less desirable choice for areas prone to ice buildup in winter.
3. Initial Cost vs. Long-Term Value
Concrete might cost less upfront, but without a warranty and with inevitable repairs, it may not be the most cost-effective choice long term. Repairing cracks can be costly, especially if an entire section needs to be redone.
Paver Patios: Pros and Cons
Pavers have become increasingly popular for Colorado patios, and it’s easy to see why. Pavers come in a variety of materials like brick, stone, and even concrete and offer greater durability and flexibility.
1. Durability and Flexibility
Pavers are more durable than concrete in Colorado’s freeze-thaw cycles. Their high compaction rate, typically around 8,000 PSI (compared to 4,000 PSI for concrete), means they withstand shifting and erosion better. Pavers also come with a longer warranty (Aspenwood Landscape offers a 3 year warranty), giving homeowners peace of mind. If settling or shifting causes pavers to sink or become uneven, individual pavers can be removed, the area can be re-graded and compacted, and the pavers can be replaced to look as good as new.
2. Maintenance Needs
Like concrete, pavers benefit from sealing every few years to protect against sun fading and stains. However, pavers generally require less maintenance than stamped concrete. For homeowners who prefer a low-maintenance option, pavers offer long-lasting beauty with minimal upkeep. If one paver is damaged, it is easily replaced without having to completely demolish and redo the entire project.
3. Aesthetics and Customization
Pavers provide more options for customization than concrete. With choices in color, texture, and size, homeowners can create a unique, custom look that matches their vision. Pavers are excellent for flat areas, but uneven terrain might require a small retaining wall to keep the pavers in place. This makes them ideal for patios, though walkways with steep slopes may benefit more from concrete.
4. Initial Cost vs. Long-Term Value
Pavers are more expensive upfront, costing around $30 per square foot. However, their durability, repair options, and warranty make them a smart investment for long-term value. The ability to replace single pavers rather than an entire section significantly lowers potential repair costs over the years.
Colorado Patio Considerations, Concrete vs. Patio chart comparison of durability, maintenance, aesthetic options, repairability, slip resistance, cost, enviornmental factors
Eco-Friendly and Longevity Factors
For homeowners concerned about sustainability, pavers offer environmental advantages. Certain paver options are permeable, allowing water to drain through and reducing runoff, a critical factor in Colorado’s semi-arid climate. This permeability also helps prevent erosion and keeps patios stable. Concrete, by contrast, does not allow water to drain, which can lead to more runoff and erosion over time.
Aspenwood’s Recommended Solution: Pavers
Given Colorado’s challenging weather and the need for durability, flexibility, and long-term value, Aspenwood Landscaping recommends pavers as the best choice for patios. Their high compaction strength, easy repair process, and long-term warranty make them a sound investment. Aspenwood’s installation process ensures quality, including removing 6-8 inches of dirt, compacting the soil, and installing drain rock and granite chips for better drainage and longevity.
Questions to Ask Your Patio Landscaping Contractor
When selecting a contractor to install your patio, here are some essential questions to consider:
What materials do you recommend for my specific property conditions and why?
What steps do you take to prepare the foundation for the patio?
(For concrete) Do you compact the soil and add a base layer before pouring?
(For pavers) How deep do you dig, and do you use drainage rock?
Do you offer a warranty on the installation?
What is the process for repairs if damage occurs?
Can individual pavers be replaced, or will sections of concrete need demolition?
What are the ongoing maintenance needs for each material?
Choosing the right patio material in Colorado involves considering the unique weather, terrain, and your future maintenance preferences. While concrete might seem budget-friendly, the frequent need for repairs and lack of flexibility may cost more in the long run. Pavers, though initially more expensive, offer the best blend of durability, ease of repair, and aesthetic options, especially in challenging climates like Colorado’s. For a patio that stands the test of time, Aspenwood Landscaping recommends pavers as a practical and attractive choice.
Ready to take the next step? Contact us today!
